UPDATE: Please welcome Willa Bea!
We loved Clara, but it doesn’t work with a strong K sound in our last name. Up until the last minute, she could have been Tessa, Nella, or Lola (love this name!) but when she was born, we fell in love with Willa Bea. I wasn’t sure about wallaby at first, but as soon as she was in my arms, it seemed like the sweetest nickname. And it is! Thank you so much for all of the help. – Holly
Holly writes:
Our second daughter is due on Christmas Eve! Her big sister is Gemma Lou. It’s the perfect name. We have a hyphenated last name for a grand total of five syllables, so we wanted short and easy. But not common. Of course! Just like everybody else, we wanted to be different. 😉
We thought of Gemma in one single conversation. And I wondered how it took couples so many weeks to find a great name. Well – ha! Karma!
The names we like are either too long with our surname – Eloise, Juniper, Josephine – or I know one already – Isla, Stella, Ruby. We do like Georgia, but my partner comes from a family where all the siblings have the same first initial, so another G name is a no.
It seems like all we know is what we don’t want, but I’ll add one more: no Christmas names. I get asked sometimes if I was born at Christmas. (My birthday is in July.) So I don’t think I want my daughter to be Ivy or Winter or Snow. (Or maybe it wouldn’t be so bad, because she could say yes when people ask her?)
Lou comes from names in both of our families, first and last. We’re thinking about Bea/Bee for this daughter, for similar reasons.
Please help!
Read on for my response and leave your thoughtful suggestions in the comments.
Abby replies:
Congratulations on your new daughter! Gemma Lou is perfect.
So we need short, sparky, and (probably) nickname-proof. Almost certainly not Top 100, but also not too unusual. For reference, Gemma ranks #198 as of 2019.
Ideally, it will work with the middle name Bea/Bee, too. That part tripped me up a little. Some names feel too cute with mini middles. Others just plain repeat the same sounds. I dropped Thea – even though it’s great with Gemma. It might be worth putting Bea aside until you’ve settled on your first name, and then circling back.
But for our purposes, we’ll work with Bea/Bee.
A SISTER FOR GEMMA LOU
CELIA (#863)
Cecilia is a long and lovely name. The shorter Celia is not only less common, but also might work better as a sister for Gemma. Plus, Celia Bea is all kinds of darling without crossing the line to twee.
DAPHNE (#432)
Gemma and Daphne share the same sparky energy.
ELIZA (#119)
Yes, it’s three syllables. But there’s something smooth and complete about Eliza.
FLORA (#936)
Cora and Nora would work nicely, but the Top 100 names feel a little too popular. How ’bout Flora? Like Gemma, it’s a gentle nature-adjacent name.
MARGOT (#304)
Originally short for Margaret, Margot has long stood on its own. It’s an energetic, modern-sounding name, but grounded in plenty of history.
NOLA (#606)
The -ola ending had a moment during the twentieth century. Now Lola is back, and Nola, too. It brings to mind New Orleans. Nola can be short for half-a-dozen names, but it also stands nicely on its own.
WILLA (#354)
You mentioned Stella. Would Willa substitute? The vibe is a little different, but the sounds are similar.
ZARA (#238)
It sounds like Sarah-with-a-Z, but Zara has several possible sources. Just like Gemma reads as classic-with-a-twist, so does Zara. That makes it an obvious match. Another Z name that might fit is Zelda (#662).
Margot and Daphne strike me as the obvious sister names for Gemma. But if you love the flow of Gemma Lou, I wonder if something like Celia Bea or Willa Bea isn’t the better choice?
Sylvie
Anya
Nadia
Navy (tho Navy Bea sounds a lot like Navy Bean)
Celie
Remy/Remi
Audrey
Celia Bea is lovely! From Abby’s list, that gets my vote.
I was wondering, too, if you might reconsider the longer names you like. Juniper Smithy-Jonstonby (made that up) doesn’t sound bad to me. If it does to you, though, by all means, strike it. Plus, Juni and Gemma are a cute match, but don’t technically share an initial. But if it reminds you too much of the all-same-initial-siblings idea that you want to avoid, by all means, strike it.
Hope you can find a name you love!
Seconding:
Tessa,
Eden, and
Cora
Alma
Fern
Zora
Delphine/Delfina
Opal
Viola
Irene
Sylvie
Talia
Maeve
Coral
Inez
since you like Georgia but can’t use it then maybe Aurora (Rory), Leona (nickname Lennie! ), Natalie (can’t decide if this is too strongly tied to Christmas or not since it’s pretty well used for babies of all birth months), and Miranda (nicknames galore here too) but perhaps those are all too long with the last name and not sure if you want a name that shortens to a nickname.
Names that feel similar in style to Gemma:
Tessa, Eden, Brooke, Hallie (love this but probably won’t work since you’re name is Holly), Zoe, Luna, Keira, Ainsley. And I know you don’t want a Christmas name but I can’t help but suggest Noelle. It’s such a beautiful name and fits in nicely with Gemma.
From all the suggestions my picks would be Margot, Eden, and Noelle.
Your* name, had to fix that! Haha
Pearl, Iris or Daisy? Mary is familiar but nowhere near as popular as one would assume(#126). Marie is even less popular (#649) but it might share too many sounds with Bea/Bee.
Honestly love the sound of Gemma Lou and Daisy Bea!
Daphne and Margot would be perfect!! I also like Zara.
If you decide to embrace the holiday bday, I love Ivy with Gemma and Bea.
You could also go with Phoebe and have the “be” ending be a nod to the Bea/Bee family connection and then choose another middle.
A few others:
Nora
Cora
Lyla
Bonnie
Ingrid
Ines
Britta
Estelle
Sylvie
Twila
Zella
Josie
No wonder y’all are having a hard time, Gemma Lou is such a fabulous name! Do you pronounce it with the “g” like gem or in Spanish? Either way super cute! Willa Bea is cute if you’re not worried about it being too close to Gemma. I do think a Christmas-y name would be fine since she could say yes, but I wonder if it might feel too matchy with your name?
Take care and best wishes to your whole family.
I love Daphne so this is another enthusiastic vote for that one. Or what about Trudie?
Flora and Nola are SO pretty and have those wonderful vintage vibes. I also like Eliza -adjacent Izzy and Margot-adjacent Perla. I think Perla is similar to Ruby and perfectly paired with Gemma. I probably wouldn’t use Willa as my mind immediately went to Willoughby then wallaby. Similarly, Zara brought me straight to Zarbee’s. I think from Abby’s list I would go with Nola Bea. Otherwise, I think Perla Bea would be great.
Other gem stone names that fit your pattern: Beryl, Opal, and Sapphire.
My daughter is Willa B. (last name initial) and instead of Willoughby/wallaby being a problem, it’s adorable. Not a thing to worry about in this case.
Willa, Eliza, or Flora get my vote!
Short, sparkly, nickname proof? I was coming down here to shout DAPHNE so I’m soo happy to see Abby already got it. My daughter is Daphne and i constantly get compliments on it. It’s truly a sweet spot name, everyone knows it but nobody knows one. It’s tailored but feminine.