Name Help: Sophie or Elodie?

They’re down to two names: Sophie or Elodie. Let’s help them make the final choice!

SARA WRITES:

We are expecting our first child, a daughter, in April. After going through ALL the names, my partner and I agree on two: Sophie or Elodie.

Depending on the day, we think one is our favorite. But then we change our minds. I’m hoping that some outside opinions will help us finally choose.

Here are our (mostly shared) thoughts about both names and other details that might help:

• SOPHIE was a name I really liked, but I’m worried that she’ll be one of many. (I’m a Sara, used to being in a crowd of Sarahs/Saras.)
• ELODIE is a name that we kept coming back to when we searched. I like that it’s different, but is it actually very trendy? My partner has a trendy 1990s name with a different spelling, and feels strongly about avoiding anything like that.
• Our child’s last name will be Arn01d, like the male name.
• We don’t have any good ideas for middle names, and keep coming back to the obvious ones, like Leigh, Grace, Mae, and Rose. There aren’t any family names we want to use.

So, which first name? And any great idea for middle names? We’re open to suggestions and feel like we’re running out of time.

ABBY REPLIES:

Congratulations on your new daughter!

The good news: you really can’t go wrong with either name.

Now for the challenging part: I think you’re pretty spot-on with your assessment of both names.

Name your daughter Sophie, and she probably will sometimes be called Sophia, or even find her name misspelled Sofia. The names are similar, and we’re all used to hearing them. Sophia has ranked in the US Top Ten since 2006; Sofia cracked the Top 20 in 2011 and is still there, too.

Elodie, on paper, is far less common. It only entered the US Top 700 in 2022, and was virtually unknown before then. But it does feel like a name on many parents’ shortlists. Millie Bobby Brown just starred in a Netflix movie as an Elodie – a princess who battles a dragon – not a bad role model, actually. And if you shorten her name to Ellie or Ella, well … then it’s a powerfully popular name again.

But here are some other things to consider:

Even a Top Ten name isn’t as common as it used to be. Gone are the days where every third girl is Mary. While I know many adult women named Sarah or Sara, I know relatively few young children with names that repeat. My son’s Top Ten name didn’t repeat in his class until middle school, and even then, not terribly often.

There are trending names, and then there are trendy ones. The difference is subtle, but important. A name like Josephine or Eliza feels traditional. But both have actually trended upward in use dramatically in recent years. Likewise, Elodie has plenty of history. It’s gaining, but that doesn’t mean it’s not a great name with history to spare.

CHOOSING BETWEEN TWO NAMES

So how do you choose? Here are the critical differences I can see between the two names.

• How do you feel about nicknames? While every name can be shortened, it’s hard to imagine Sophie routinely being called anything other than Sophie. Elodie, on the other hand, lends itself to Ellie and Dee, for starters. If avoiding nicknames matters, that’s one point for Sophie. If embracing them is your style, then one point for Elodie.
• Do you want your daughter’s name to stand out? While Sophie probably won’t be one in a crowd, her name also won’t surprise most people. Elodie, on the other hand, is the kind of name unusual enough to invite comment. It’s impossible to know how your child will eventually feel about this, but you can think about your feelings.

MIDDLE NAME IDEAS

SOPHIE ____ ARN0lD

Because Sophie is a fairly popular name, I’d suggest a bolder middle. Because both the first and last names are two-syllables, something shorter or longer feels right.

• Sophie Wren
• Sophie Blythe
• Sophie Coraline

ELODIE ARN01D

Conversely, Elodie is a less common name, so something a little more familiar works. Also, I really like a one-syllable middle with three-syllable Elodie and a two-syllable surname.

• Elodie Jane
• Elodie Sage/Saige
• Elodie Vale

SOPHIE or ELODIE?

I’d spend some time thinking about popularity and nicknames to help make your decision. If you both share strong opinions about one of those issues, then the choice might become obvious.

If you’re still stuck, I like this approach, too: flip a coin. Heads for Sophie, tails for Elodie. Let’s say it lands on heads: Sophie. How do you feel? At peace? Or is your immediate impulse to go for two out of three? If you sit with the results of the coin flip for a few hours – or even days – there’s a good chance you’ll either be grateful to have the decision made or recognize that it’s not the right call. Either way, you’ll have an answer.

No matter what, though, rest in the knowledge that these are both great names for your daughter.

Readers, what do you think: Sophie or Elodie? Middle name ideas welcome, too!