What happens to once-fashionable names? Do they fade away, or do we see them in a different light?
Thanks to Shan for suggesting Eustace as our Baby Name of the Day.
I would be shocked to meet a baby boy Eustace.
But very, extremely, astonishingly surprised.
Eustace hasn’t cracked the US Top 1000 in over a century. You’d have to go back to the 1920s to find a year when more than a dozen newborns answered to Eustace.
Eustace comes from a Greek name meaning fruitful, or more generally, good fortune.
There’s the inevitable second century martyr saint and Latin form of the name: Eustachius.
The saint was a Christian convert, and because he was inspired to convert after a vision during a hunting trip, he’s the patron saint of hunters. He suffered like Job but held fast to this faith. There’s a gory story about Eustace his death by fire.
It may be nothing but legend, but he was a big deal in the Middle Ages.
- The Counts of Boulogne from the eleventh through twelfth century used the name frequently. The fourth Eustace would have been king of England – his dad, Stephen, had claimed the throne. But he died before his father.
- A twelfth-century Bishop of London wore the name.
- Then there’s Eustace the Monk – though he was mostly an outlaw. Born near Boulogne in the thirteenth century, the stories about him are incredible. He studied black magic, became a monk – briefly, left the monastery to avenge his father’s death, quarreled with the local Count, and generally caused a ruckus.
- Despite a respectable family, Eustace Folville became a notorious criminal in the 1500s. His exploits included murder, theft, and kidnapping, to name a few. Folville was never brought to justice, and he ended his days as a respectable member of the community. Some accounts give him a Robin Hood-like status.
- An eighteenth century writer wore the name, Eustace Budgell, though he lost his fortune and ended badly. (I mention him only because that his picture above.)
So Eustace was a hero and a scoundrel, a ruler and a saint. The name must have been thoroughly wearable in the day.
In the twentieth century, Eustace was anything but.
First there’s the Chronicles of Narnia character. In the words of C. S. Lewis, “There once was a boy called Eustace Clarence Scrubb, and he almost deserved it.”
Scrubb starts out an arrogant, whiny brat. He spends some time as a dragon. If you read to the end of the series, you’ll know that ultimately Eustace proves himself heroic – it’s the kind of redemption that could make Eustace a Neville name – but most of us think of the character from the early books.
Then there’s Eustace Tilley, the monocle-sporting dandy who has graced many a New Yorker magazine cover. The humorist Corey Ford gave the character his name in the 1920s, inspired by a maiden aunt’s surname and a Columbia classmate’s first name.
Lastly, I think of Eustace Bagge, the crotchety, cruel senior on Courage the Cowardly Dog.
Speaking of courage, it would take a lot to revive Eustace. Still, if Trace is hot for boys, does the prospect of Stace – combined with his rich history – offer any hope for Eustace?
Original photo: Eustace Budgell Esqr., via Library of Congress
I adore the name Eustace, have done for years since I studied King Stephen and it’s my first choice boy’s name. But everyone’s comments and aversion to it, not to mention the ‘useless’ jibes, does put me off! I wouldn’t want to set my son up for a fail…
I think I know what happened to the name Eustace…people realized it was horrid and stopped using it.
I like Eustacia for a girl. Although I’ve seen Eustacie used for both sex. I think of the female character: Eustacie De Vauban from “The Talisman Ring” by Georgette Heyer.
Waltzing More Than Matilda says
I would be surprised to meet one too!
I keep thinking of Eustace Scrubb in “The Silver Chair”, where an elderly and very deaf dwarf mishears Eustace as “Useless”. Even for fans, that’s quite a put-off.
I do think Eustace Scrubb was named after Saint Eustace, because he was also a convert, and of course his surname indicates that his soul was “scrubbed clean”.
So a great name for the character, for a real life person, not so much.
That’s all I can think of too! “I dare say he’s useless” just puts me off unfortunately. But somehow I do still find Eustace a bit appealing, perhaps in sound and theory more than real life. Like you said, a great character name.
A boy named Eustace has big time Narnia fan parents. And probably several older brothers who already snagged Peter, Edmund, and Caspian.
Yes, Peter, Edmund, and Caspian are all on my list. 😉 Peter’s out, though, unfortunately.
When I was in college, I attended Michigan State University. As a name nerd, I loved the cool names of the buildings as well as their history as well. One of the buildings is called Eustace Cole, which immediately came to mind when I saw this post. Here’s a link to check it out. Apparently, it was named after the head of the Horticulture dept, William Eustace, but I like it better as a first name as opposed to a last. It has a nice literary sound to it. 🙂
One of my favorite lines in all of literature is that Eustace Clarence Scrubb one from C. S. Lewis. I read all of the books and he does turn out to be a great hero, but there’s no way that I could ever imagine a Eustace born today.
Yes, not a lot of love for Eustace. Its international versions don’t improve things either, like the Spanish Eustaquio.
That’s the Spanish version? Yikes! But that’s a good point – sometimes translating a name saves it. Other times, not so much …
Eustace was a joke name my siblings and I used to call each other as kids – I think we must have heard it on some TV show – so yeah, not a fan. It kind of has a backwoods vibe to me, like Cletus and Lurleen.
St-Eustache church is a lovely place to visit in the centre of Paris, next to Les Halles. It’s no Notre-Dame cathedral, of course, but beautiful, historic and interesting all the same.
This might be my least-favorite name.
I knew a Eustace a few years back. I think he was a IV or maybe even a V. He went by Harry. 🙂
I actually kind of like Eustace and also Eustacia.