• Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Request a Name

Appellation Mountain

Where every name has a story

  • Baby Name Advice & More
  • Master List: Girl Names
  • Master List: Boy Names
  • Private Baby Name Consulting

Name Help: Twins Bring Double Naming Challenges

October 9, 2020 By appellationmountain 18 Comments

Name Help: Boy-Girl TwinsName Help is a series at Appellation Mountain. Every week, one reader’s name questions will be discussed. We’re relying on thoughtful comments from the community to help expectant parents narrow down their name decisions. Thank you in advance for sharing your insight!

Lisa writes:

We are due with boy-girl twins in January, but it looks like they’ll probably be here before the end of the year. Getting here has been a struggle, and we’ve avoided talking about names until now.

For our son, we know we don’t want him to inherit my husband’s name. My husband is a III, and while his family would like us to pass down the name again, he’s not on board. We’ll use James as his middle name, instead.

We’ve even debated using my husband’s full name, James Oliver – so our son has two middle names. Our last name is a common, two syllable H name, so we don’t mind a long name.

First names feel hard, though. We’ve narrowed our list to:

  1. August – but is this weird for a winter baby?
  2. Jude – except JJ bothers me
  3. Wesley – but I’m not sure about Wes

I think we could be happy with any of these.

For our daughter, we’re all over the place. No first name seems right, and we really don’t have a middle name that we want to use from my family. (There are some we could use from his, but I think my family would feel like that was too much.) The only name we both don’t dislike – so far – is Maria. But we agree it doesn’t feel like her name, if that makes sense.

Where do we even begin?

Please read on for my response and leave your thoughtful suggestions in the comments.

Dear Lisa –

First, congratulations on your children! Naming twins is a twice the challenge – and maybe a little more, too. Not only do you have to choose two names you love, there’s a sense that the names need to balance – probably more than if you were naming a brother for your older daughter, or vice versa.

Let’s start with boy names, though, because you’re almost there.

AUGUST, JUDE, OR WESLEY?

I’d describe your style as gentlemanly traditionals. They’re masculine, but they’re not swinging-through-the-saloon-doors kind of guys. They’re a little more polished and thoughtful, but still strong.

Gentlemanly traditionals – these are not the guys swinging through the saloon doors in the Wild West. (Though I suppose they could.)

So let’s not add to your list. Instead, let’s talk about your three favorites.

First, Wesley. Some names have default nicknames, like Benjamin-called-Ben. I’d put Wesley almost in this category. I’ve known people with this name who never shorten it. But it’s something of an obvious choice. If Wes bothers you, I’d strike this name off the list. It’s just too likely that it would stick.

Jude James being called JJ, on the other hand? It certainly could happen. Kids come home from school (and camp and sports practice and play rehearsal) with all sorts of daffy nicknames. JJ isn’t unimaginable. But it’s not automatic. And even if your son’s baseball team called him JJ, well … you certainly wouldn’t have to do the same.

That leaves August. Contrary to our impression, August doesn’t mean “peak summer.” It means venerable; after all, Augustus started out as a title for the Roman emperor. So it seems like fair game to name a baby August any month of the year. Do I hear the crashing waves of the ocean with this name? A little. But it also sounds like a name that belongs in front of a roaring fire, a brother for Emmett. I’d say it fits with homespun boy names – just like Jude and Wesley.

Between August and Jude, I think I’d favor Jude – if only because you don’t have to think about the question of seasons. But let’s wait until we find a name for your daughter, and then revisit the question.

NAMES FOR YOUR DAUGHTER

I can imagine Maria as a sister for Wesley, August, or Jude – but it might not be my first thought. Let’s see if we can find something feminine, traditional, but still with some current style.

ALICE – A storybook name with a lot of strength.

ELEANOR – Classic and polished.

JULIET – A little more romantic, maybe closer to Maria than Eleanor.

NORA – Everyone loves Nora, a choice that’s both timeless and current at once.

RUBY – A gemstone name with a straightforward sound.

STELLA – The meaning – star – is gorgeous, and the sound is perfect with August or Jude.

THEA – A short, sparky name that’s on the rise.

WILLA – Willa strikes me as homespun name in the key of August.

PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER

If you agree with my conclusions so far, we’re down to two possible boy names: August James or Jude James.

Now here’s where I want to suggest something about your daughter’s middle. How about Olivia? It splits up your husband’s family name between the siblings.

If not Olivia, would you consider Elisabeth or Elise? Or something else that nods to your name? (Lisette, Lys, just Lisa?) I’ve also seen Isla suggested, since it’s an anagram of Lisa.

That leads me to:

  • August James and Willa Olivia
  • August James and Juliet Elise
  • Jude James and Ruby Olivia
  • Jude James and Alice Elisabeth
  • Jude James and Nora Elise
  • Jude James and Thea Olivia

I think that last one – Jude James and Thea Olivia – is my favorite. But I’ll be so curious to hear what readers think about this one!

What names would you suggest for Lisa’s boy-girl twins? Any tips for handling the family name issue?

More names you might like:

  • Name Help: Fourth Four-Letter Boy NameName Help: Fourth Four-Letter Boy Name
  • Name Help: A Sister for Liam ElizabethName Help: A Sister for Liam Elizabeth
  • Name Help: Same-Named CousinsName Help: Same-Named Cousins
  • Name Help: A Sister for Kellan and KendallName Help: A Sister for Kellan and Kendall
  • Name Help: A Sister for Nora ClairName Help: A Sister for Nora Clair

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print

Comments

  1. Jaime says

    October 11, 2020 at 9:38 PM

    I like August and Jude for a boy. Instead of Wesley, maybe West?

    With August, I like the suggestion of Nora. Or maybe Lydia, Eleanor or Juliet?

    With Jude, maybe Zoe, Mia, Sophie, Piper, Tess, or Ivy?

    If you’re giving your son a family name, Is strongly urge you to use one for your daughter as well (maybe even your first, middle or maiden name). If not a family name, then one with some special meaning for you…even if you just like the meaning of a particular name.

    Reply
  2. the Mrs. says

    October 11, 2020 at 12:18 AM

    I’m here to suggest the name of a beloved princess: Marina.

    She’s elegant and stately but sweet and feminine.

    If you DO choose the most excellent name of August James for your son, I love how they would share a “royal” connection… which is a nice, subtle, twin link.

    Also, both August and Marina have a cool, beachy vibe… like the awesomeness of each of their names is magnified by the other.

    I’d also encourage you to use YOUR first name of middle name for your daughter’s middle name. Children who love their parents love special connections with them; you’re giving them legacy and belonging.

    Congratulations and best wishes on your double blessings!!

    Reply
  3. Zena Eve says

    October 10, 2020 at 3:31 PM

    Well, if you can’t ever quite decide between August, Jude, and Wesley:
    Seth
    Clark
    Xavier
    Vincent
    Adam
    Donovan
    Ira

    Girls are a bit harder since the only definitive is not Maria.
    Irene
    Alma
    Teresa
    Vivian
    Leona
    Isadora
    Harriet
    Rosemary

    Reply
  4. Jean C. says

    October 10, 2020 at 12:55 PM

    Congratulations on your twins! I feel like August is perfect for a winter baby! In fact, Augustus was the name I had picked out for my son long before getting pregnant with him—and then when I had him IN August I was like nope. Just can’t. It’s just too cheesy! But it’s PERFECT in every other month. I think August James or August James Oliver is perfect. Jude is too choppy with James (but would sound fine as Jude Oliver I think).
    Since both Jude and August(us) were on my list, I wonder if you would like some of the girl names I have loved and wished for and opportunity to use? Evangeline (already mentioned here!), Violet, Margaret, Matilda, Cecilia, Felicity, Miriam, Ramona, Eloise or evening just Louise. My daughter is named Gloria, which works surprisingly well on a toddler—we call her Glo frequently and it has a fun spunky vibe that suits her. Out of Abby’s suggestions, I think Eleanor is my favorite. August and Eleanor could be nicknamed Gus and Nora if you felt so inclined, although not intuitively enough that they’re sure to be shortened like Wesley/Wes. I do agree with a previous commenter that while I love Juliet, if anyone said them in the order “Juliet and August” it is going to just bring listing months to mind.
    August James and Eleanor Maria
    August James and Evangeline Lisette
    August James Oliver and Matilda Evangeline
    August James and Felicity Maria
    August James and Marie Eleanor
    (A previous commenter mentioned Marie instead of Maria and I also wonder if it might be a little closer to what you’re looking for and I love it).

    Reply
  5. LilySong says

    October 10, 2020 at 8:22 AM

    Of the suggestions above, August James is my favourite. Jude James doesn’t sound right since it’s 2 1-syllable names. It’s too choppy. I LOVE August & Eleanor together. Gorgeous!! How about
    August James & Eleanor Lisa
    August James & Eleanor Liesel
    August James & Eleanor Isabelle
    August James & Lenore Elizabeth
    August James & Lenore Elise
    August James & Lenore Eloise
    August James & Leora Elizabeth
    If you use James Oliver gor baby boy’s mn, please use two middles for baby girl. Otherwise it seems lopsided.
    August James Oliver & Eleanor Liesel Ann
    I’d keep playing with Eleanor & Elizabeth variations (there are so many!) to see what strikes me the most.
    Congratulations!

    Reply
  6. skupskia says

    October 9, 2020 at 10:11 PM

    I think Jude works well for a girl, you could have August and Jude ( I like Wesley too, but based on your comments not liking the nn, it seems like August is the way to go)

    Reply
  7. L. says

    October 9, 2020 at 8:38 PM

    I would like to suggest Oliver James for the boy twin and a Maria variant for the girl twin. Perhaps you would like one of the following:

    Mariah
    Marianne
    Maren
    Marielle
    Mia
    Miriam

    My favorites for you are:
    Oliver James and Mia Elizabeth
    Oliver James and Marianne Elise
    Oliver James and Elizabeth Marie

    Reply
  8. Anchors_and_Whales says

    October 9, 2020 at 8:08 PM

    I vote for Wesley. If you use the name in full, he likely will, too. There are lots of Thomas-not-Toms and Robert-not-Robs, Wesley doesn’t have to become Wes, or Lee.

    Wesley James has a nice flow. So does Wesley James Oliver H…

    For your girl, Maria makes me think of Marina or Mariana or Martina. Other ideas:
    Lavinia (has the Liv sound like Oliver, if desired)
    Cecelia
    Felicity
    Mirenna
    Magnolia
    Serenity

    I may be the only one who doesn’t feel the need to pass on names, but I would say, if you don’t like a name from your side, forget trying and use a name you like. If you and your husband like the name James for your boy, use it. But don’t feel obligated to please others with your children’s names. These are your children.
    So, with that in mind, I say toss the family tree and choose a name that you two like that flows well with the first name you also like.

    Possible Girl Name Combos:

    Lavinia Grace
    Mirenna Marie
    Cecelia Fay/May/Rae
    Felicity Arabella
    Mirenna Cascade
    Magnolia Blue/Rue/Lou
    Serenity Celeste/Elise

    Reply
  9. Maclary says

    October 9, 2020 at 5:54 PM

    I’m in the southern hemisphere – so August feels perfect for a winter baby to me! Seriously, I think it’s becoming common enough that it doesn’t feel too tied to the month. And it works perfectly with the middle name/s too.

    For your girl, the fact you like Maria (which would be an amazing choice!) makes me want to suggest names like Lucia, Sophia, Celia or Delia, Lydia, Erica, Nicola, Thalia … maybe even Zinnea? Or, how about Livia?

    Reply
  10. Keats says

    October 9, 2020 at 4:20 PM

    I’m loving August James. It is a great name. Truly a strong, statemanly, name. I don’t think of it as a month name any more than Mae/May.

    I also think Annalise might be a nice middle for your daughter. Has the Lise as a nod to you, but it is all her own name. So I was wondering about J first names just like several other posters.

    August James and Juliet Annalise.
    August James and Jane Annalise.
    August James and Joy Annalise

    Or I also really like

    August James and Edith (Edie) Marie
    August James and Amelia Marie
    August James and Ayla Marie
    August James and Ava Marie (perhaps that is a bit close to the hymn so maybe Ava Grace is better?)
    August James and Nora Jean
    August James and Alexandra Marie

    Congrats on your twins!

    Reply
  11. Lashley says

    October 9, 2020 at 3:33 PM

    August James and Mariel Lisette
    Jude Oliver and Maeve Eliza
    Wesley James and Juliana Lisette
    August James and Olive Elisabeth

    Reply
  12. stefanie says

    October 9, 2020 at 2:20 PM

    Am I the only one who has a hard time with Jude James? Something about that D leading into J sounds weird to me. I love August and think it’s even better for a winter baby! August James and Anna Lisa.

    Reply
    • Clara says

      October 10, 2020 at 1:15 AM

      I’m totally with you. That was my very first thought reading the original post – Jude James sounds way too choppy. (In saying that, it’s unlikely that the full name will be prounounced together on many occasions, so it may not matter, but is worth pointing out 🙂 ).

      Reply
  13. C in DC says

    October 9, 2020 at 12:37 PM

    August and Juliet = August + July to me, so that’s a warning. I love full Wesley (sure, Wes, will come around, but if you always call him Wesley, then most people will follow suit).
    August James & Vera Maria
    Wesley James & Audrey Elise
    Jude James & Annalies Olivia or Olive Lisbet
    Oliver Lisle/Lyle & Eliza Jane

    Reply
  14. Renée says

    October 9, 2020 at 11:46 AM

    I would REALLY like to see you use Lisa in the middle spot for your daughter. Since boy twin is definitely getting one if not two of his dad’s names, it seems balanced and fair for her to get your name. If Lisa butts against a name ending in A and you don’t like the sound – Lise is quite lovely.

    Wondering if you could repurpose any of the boy name sounds for a girl? The fact that you can agree on Maria makes me think you like longer flowy names for girls? (love Abby’s suggestion of Juliet – perfection with August!) So how about:

    Augusta Lise & Wesley James
    Aurelia Lise & Wesley James
    Julia Lise & August James
    Juliana Lise & Wesley James
    Genevieve Lisa & Jude Oliver James
    Waverly Lisa & August James
    Wilhelmina Lise & Jude Oliver James

    Or use Olive for girl twin with your name in the middle? Olive is closer to the sound of Oliver plus less common and better matched to your boy choices, in my opinion.
    Olive Lisa & Wesley James

    Reply
  15. Amy3 says

    October 9, 2020 at 10:40 AM

    I had also thought of using Olivia as the middle name for your daughter so you can split your husband’s name between the twins. I personally like August James for your son. For a daughter, would you consider Josephine?

    Reply
  16. Aine says

    October 9, 2020 at 10:11 AM

    I was definitely thinking that Lisa or a Lisa-related name would be the perfect middle for your daughter! Abby’s idea to use Olivia is also brilliant, and I think Olive could also work well if you’re averse to double “a” endings.

    Georgia
    Gemma
    Gwen
    Lucy/Lucia/Louise
    Maude or Matilda
    Laura
    Iris
    Violet
    Tessa or Theresa/Teresa
    Kate
    Helen
    Anne
    Rose/Rosalie/Rosa

    Reply
  17. Yellow says

    October 9, 2020 at 8:17 AM

    What about Marie for your daughter if Maria doesn’t feel right? I have a nearly four year old Marie and we get compliments all the time.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter


POPULAR POSTS

Tweets by @appmtn
Visit Appellation Mountain's profile on Pinterest.

Copyright © 2023 · AppellationMountain.net on Genesis Framework · Privacy Policy · Log in