Name Help is a series at Appellation Mountain. Every week, we discuss reader’s name questions, usually on Tuesdays and Fridays. We’re relying on thoughtful comments from the community to help expectant parents narrow down their name decisions. Thank you in advance for sharing your insight! To have your question considered, email appmtn (at) gmail. Looking for your own private #namehelp post? Order one here.

ANOTHER GIRL NAME LIKE AUDREY

Kellie writes:

I picked out our daughter’s name, Audrey Meadow, when I was in middle school. It turns out there was an actress named Audrey Meadows from the 1950s. Maybe I heard her name somewhere? I did think about Audrey Hepburn at some point, and I love the way the name’s image has this sort of legendary, Old Hollywood glamour without being too overwhelming or dramatic.

I like the way it works with our long last name: Constant-plus-ino. But I also like that it’s not so short that it gets overwhelmed by it.

My husband agreed to Audrey in part because I agreed to his favorite name for a boy: Jason. It’s a little overdone, I know. But it’s from his favorite actor and I do appreciate that it’s a name everyone knows but there won’t necessarily be another Jason in his class.

Except now we’re having another girl, and neither of us has much of a list to start from. At this point, we don’t even have a short list. The only name we were seriously considering was Evelyn, but good friends just used that name for their daughter a few months ago and there’s no way we can use it now, too.

We are thinking about the middle name Estelle, which is for his grandmother but also because my due date is the day after Christmas and I like the way it’s a little bit for the holiday without being super obvious.

But for a first name, lots of things are okay but nothing stands out and we are really running out time.

Please read on for my response and leave your thoughtful suggestions in the comments.

sleeping baby girl wrapped in blanket wearing floral headband; names like Audrey
Get new posts sent to your inbox!
Don’t miss out! Subscribe and get all the new posts first.

TIMELESS NAMES FOR GIRLS

Abby replies:

Congratulations on your new daughter!

Naming a second child can be tough. We spend so much time choosing our first child’s name. More than a decade sometimes, right? So it’s crazy to realize we have to do it AGAIN and we have months or even weeks.

But I do think there are some guidelines we can follow based on your description:

  • Audrey strikes a good balance between playful and sophisticated. Credit to Ms. Hepburn, of course, but it’s more than that. We’re looking for a name with enough history to immediately feel at-home on a child or an adult.
  • The right name will be nickname-proof while still offering a distinctive, straightforward sound. Names like Elle or Mae get swallowed up by longer, consonant-heavy surnames. But a name like Anastasia or Elodie can become a tongue-twister. We’re looking for something in-between.
  • You’re drawn to popular favorites, but only if they have history. For every Evelyn, there’s a Lainey. Also a great name, but I suspect you’re drawn to choices that feel timeless. They work for a child born now, but you can also imagine them on someone from 1956 or 1886.

Since it seems like you both agree on Estelle, I’m also going to avoid anything that conflicts with Estelle as a middle name, so no Isabelle or Eloise.

Based on all of that, let’s start coming up with a shortlist.

NAMES LIKE AUDREY

ALICE

A story book name that sounds lady-like and also full of adventure, classic Alice is at home in any era. It is two A names, and parents don’t always like to repeat initials, but I do think these names pair beautifully together.

DAPHNE

Thanks to Bridgerton and a few other high-profile uses, Daphne has climbed in use. But it’s really just the next logical Greek girls’ name ending with E, following Zoe, Chloe, and Penelope. Any of those would work well, but I really like Daphne as a sister for Audrey. I think that’s subtle sharing of the D sound.

LYDIA

I almost left Lydia off this list. I’ve met a real life pair of sisters named Audrey and Lydia, the daughters of a mother who is an excellent, thoughtful namer. So while I hesitated to suggest a duplicate, I can’t think of a better sister name for Audrey than Lydia, especially with the middle name Estelle and with your surname.

MARGOT

A sophisticated but upbeat name everyone loves right now … but also everyone has loved across the years, too.

NORA

Like Audrey, there’s something slightly understated about Nora. It’s a strong name, but not a wildly elaborate stand-out. In a classroom with kids called Wrenleigh and Khaleesi and Dallas, there’s something about Nora’s cool, enduring style that shines.

RACHEL

Some might dismiss Rachel as a name from the 1980s, 90s or early 2000s. And the name did have a really good run, immortalized by Friends and Rachael Ray and Rachel Zegler, too. But this name properly belongs with the classics, an Old Testament choice blending feminine style with a distinctive sound.

SELAH

If Rachel and Nora have been around for ages, Selah is a relative newcomer. On paper, it claims Old Testament roots. But it’s more of a vocabulary term, a direction to pause, rather than a personal name. Still, Selah is an obvious successor to Sarah and Sophia, a flowing name with a measure of sophistication.

VALERIE

There’s so much energy to Valerie; there’s a reason it features in at least three song titles. Vivacious and current across the decades, Valerie is the kind of name everyone recognizes, even if it’s never reached the US Top 50.

Overall, I’m having a really hard time choosing a favorite. I’m ping-ponging between Lydia, Rachel, and Daphne. Since Estelle is a strong contender for a middle name, I’ll use that to make my top two choices Daphne Estelle and Lydia Estelle.

Readers over to you! Can you suggest more girl names like Audrey for their new daughter?

About Abby Sandel

Whether you're naming a baby, or just all about names, you've come to the right place! Appellation Mountain is a haven for lovers of obscure gems and enduring classics alike.

You May Also Like:

What do you think?

5 Comments

  1. Irene Estelle Const@ntino

    Audrey & Irene

    Maren Estelle Const@ntino

    Audrey & Maren

    Simone Estelle Const@ntino

    Audrey & Simone

    Vera Estelle Const@ntino

    Audrey & Vera

  2. Just a few more suggestions for Audrey Meadow’s sister:

    Ines (or Inez)

    Dahlia

    Loretta

    Vivian (*I know it is popular, but works well I think)

    Sasha/Sascha

    Love the suggestions of Margot, Greta & Delphine too!

  3. Ooh, this is a fun one! I love the suggestion of Lydia. It’s my niece’s name (she’s almost two) and they get lots of compliments on it.

    Leaning into the subtle nod to old Hollywood, may I suggest Greta, Katherine, and Greer.

    Mariel, Liza, and Gemma also come to mind.

    Clara would be another way to honor Christmastime. Natalia, too – maybe “Talia” for short.

    Wishing you the best with daughter #2!

  4. Congratulations on daughter #2!

    Audrey Meadow is a lovely, whimsical name, understandably hard to match.

    I really like Abby’s suggestions of Nora, Margot & Daphne, but, the A ending of the first name makes Estelle harder to say, at least for me. So Margot & Daphne are my favourites.

    I’m surprised Abby didn’t suggest Sylvie. Sylvie Estelle is magical & goes so nicely with Audrey!

    If you like Margot but want something more unique, how about Magalie?

    If Daphne is nice but not quite right, how about Delphine?