Name Help is a series at Appellation Mountain. Every week, one reader’s name questions will be discussed. We’re relying on thoughtful comments from the community to help expectant parents narrow down their name decisions. Thank you in advance for sharing your insight! To have your question considered, email appmtn (at) gmail. Looking for your own private #namehelp post? Order one here.

CONTINUING THE PATTERN FOR BABY NUMBER FOUR

Molly writes:

We have a long, hyphenated last name and so when our son was born, we quickly agreed on Jude. Short, easy, all the things.

Four years later, we named our twins Claire and Finn. Same thinking, but it was maybe a little harder because it felt like we had to rule out names that were close to Jude. (We both really liked Jane, but agreed we didn’t want to repeat initials at that point.)

Now we’re expecting our fourth child and second girl. Given our ages, this is probably our last baby. (But we said that with the twins!)

We know that we want another one-syllable name. I think that we probably don’t want to repeat an initial and absolutely nothing rhyming/too close, so Blair and Lynn are out.

Names we have considered, but probably won’t use:

  • Kate – Feels like we should like it, but we kind of don’t. Also my partner is British and it feels a little too royal family.
  • Mae – Just not enough name there.
  • Ruth – Kind of close to Jude, and maybe a little old-fashioned.
  • Reeve – We ruled out Eve, but we kind of like Reeve. What bothers me about it: I don’t really want a unisex name, or a name that makes it sound like we wanted another son. My partner likes Reeve a lot and thinks I’m being maybe too picky, but I just think I wouldn’t want it for my name.
  • Leigh – Another name my partner likes. I just associate it with names like Kayleigh and so I can’t get on board.

The name we’re seriously considering is Maeve, but we are not at all Irish and can’t decide if that’s a problem.

Please read on for my response and leave your thoughtful suggestions in the comments.

baby girl sleeping in crocheted blanket, "name a sister for Jude, Claire, and Finn"
Get new posts sent to your inbox!
Don’t miss out! Subscribe and get all the new posts first.

FINDING SHORT, STRONG NAMES WITHOUT REPEATING SOUNDS

Abby replies:

Congratulations on your new daughter!

Here’s what leaps out at me: Maeve is The Name to Beat.

It shares sounds with Mae and Reeve, but without the drawbacks of either name. It’s a little longer, and clearly feminine, with an undeniably strong, memorable sound. And it’s distinctive as a sister for Jude, Claire, and Finn, so it succeeds on that count, too.

Is it Irish? Yes.

Just like Liam and Ryan and a very, very long list of popular favorites from the 20th and 21st centuries.

When names become very popular, they shed quite a bit of their heritage status. Isabella is a great Spanish-English crossover name, but plenty of families use the name because they just plain love it.

I’d put Maeve in the same category.

As for gender? I wish I could give as clear an answer, but the truth is this: avoiding or embracing unisex names is all down to personal preference. Since you have misgivings, I’d (probably, mostly) avoid them.

So let’s see if we can find single-syllable names for girls that feel traditional(ish) but also strong and appealing for a 2025 arrival.

FRESH SUGGESTIONS: A SISTER FOR JUDE, CLAIRE & FINN

BELLE

Isabella and Annabelle have had a moment. So has Bella. But Belle – as in the bookish beauty at the heart of a Disney fairytale – remains surprising uncommon. There’s a lot of strength to Belle, too, possibly because it feels a little like a straight-up noun name.

GWEN

Impossible to link to a specific generation, Gwen might be sweetly vintage, sparky and retro, or perfectly 21st century. It’s feminine, but nicely unexpected, too.

KIT

Is Kit too brief? It seems like a potential substitute for Kate.

ROSE

A timeless, enduring choice with a bright, unmistakable sound, a perfect sister for Jude, Claire, and Finn.

SAGE

I love Sage with your older kids’ names. Like Jude, Claire, and Finn, it’s very current – but still offers plenty of history. It’s used for boys, but is far more common for girls.

SCOUT

A literary pick that sounds principled and adventurous.

REESE

I know Reeve isn’t quite right, but have you considered Reese? It is unisex. And yet, Reese Witherspoon is such a fixture in our culture that Reese is often used for girls. As of 2023, Reese has been significantly more popular for girls for over two decades.

VALE

A little bit of a wildcard. Vale comes from a poetic word meaning valley. It’s sometimes a surname, but I think the references to the natural world keep it on the right side of unisex.

Overall, my favorite is Sage. Jude, Claire, Finn, and Sage. I think it’s quite distinctive from your older kids’ names, and while it’s slightly unisex, I think it reads feminine, particularly in this list of siblings.

If not Sage, then I’ll pick something a little more traditional and suggest Rose. It’s a perfect sister for Jude, Claire, and Finn, I think.

Of course … that’s only if I can’t convince you that Maeve really is perfect. Because I do think Maeve hits the sweet spot between Mae and Reeve, plus sounds well-matched but nicely different from your older kids’ names.

Readers, over to you! What would you name a sister for Jude, Claire, and Finn?

About Abby Sandel

Whether you're naming a baby, or just all about names, you've come to the right place! Appellation Mountain is a haven for lovers of obscure gems and enduring classics alike.

You May Also Like:

What do you think?

16 Comments

  1. Congratulations on baby number 4!

    Maeve doesnโ€™t strike me as uniquely Irish anymore than Finn or Claire now. Jude, Claire, Finn and Maeve sound great together.
    My first thought was Anne instead of Jane. They both have a classic, traditional feel.
    I also like Abbyโ€™s suggestion of Sage. Might you like the Saige spelling instead? Itโ€™s not as common as Sage, and to me, makes it definitely for a girl.
    Jude, Claire, Finn & Anne
    Jude, Claire, Finn & Saige
    Jude, Claire, Finn & Rose make a gorgeous sibset too.

  2. Isn’t Finn Irish? Finn McCool?

    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Maeve seem exactly perfect together. EXACTLY PERFECT.

    But if she just doesn’t give you the vibe you want, Abby’s suggestions of Rose and Gwen give her wonderful distinction, her own initial, and the “Great Brittan feel” the rest of your children’s names enjoy.

    Congratulations and best wishes!

  3. There’s some really good suggestions! I’ll try to not repeat:

    Amy
    Etta
    Ida
    Opal
    Rosa
    Sky
    Thea

  4. Congrats on baby #4!

    I think Maeve is a great choice and probably the name to beat. For all the reasons Abby listed, I agree it’s fine to use even if you aren’t Irish.

    Some other ideas:

    Brooke. Frills free like Reeve, feminine like Kate, more modern than Ruth. This is my top suggestion ๐Ÿ™‚
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Brooke

    Paige.
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Paige

    Tess.
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Tess

    Shay. This sounds similar to Maeve
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Shay

    Liv. Maybe this falls in the same camp as Mae and doesn’t quite feel like a whole name for you but I wanted to suggest it anyways.
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Liv

    Elle. Again, maybe not substantial enough but just an idea!
    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Elle

    1. Liv is one that didnโ€™t pop to mind. Itโ€™s a full name though everyone will think itโ€™s short for Olivia.

  5. Alsoโ€ฆthree more:

    Anne (very traditional, but still lovely)

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Anne

    Shay – both Irish & Hebrewโ€ฆ

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Shay

    Nell

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Nell

  6. Iโ€™ll list these without looking at other suggestions, so there are likely repeats:
    Anne
    Belle
    Bess
    Beth
    Blythe
    Bree
    Brynn
    Dove
    Elle
    Greer
    Hope
    Kay
    Lark
    Maeve
    Maud
    Mauve
    Nell
    Quinn
    Rae
    Rose
    Rue
    Tess
    Vere
    Wren
    Zell

  7. Hi! Congratulations on the baby who will be joining your family soon!

    Would you consider Maude instead of Maeve? Maybe it could work well. It is a name that is coming back and starting to be used more and more.

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Maude

    Also, a name I really like for you is Grace.

    Jude, Claire, Finn, and Grace.

    Some others I think could also work well include: Blythe, Pearl, and possibly Sloane, but I am not sure Sloane fits as well as the other two.

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Blythe.

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Pearl.

    Jude, Claire, Finn & Sloane.

    I think my favorites for you are Maude & Grace.

    Sending all best wishes!!